House Bill 4

Actions | Amendments
Last Action 03/11/25: passed over and retained in the Orders of the Day
Title AN ACT relating to initiatives regarding diversity, equity, and inclusion.
Bill Documents Current
Introduced
Bill Request Number 193
Sponsors J. Decker, M. Lockett, S. Baker, E. Callaway, J. Calloway, D. Elliott, D. Fister, J. Gooch Jr., D. Hale, J. Hodgson, M. Imes, K. King, C. Lewis, C. Massaroni, S. McPherson, J. Nemes, M. Proctor, T. Roberts, N. Tate, J. Tipton, T. Truett, B. Wesley, M. Whitaker, R. White
Summary of Original Version Create new sections of KRS Chapter 164 to define terms; prohibit a public postsecondary education institution from providing differential treatment or benefits on the basis of an individual's religion, race, sex, color, or national origin; from influencing the composition of the student body or scholarship recipients on the basis of religion, race, sex, color, or national origin; from implementing a student housing assignment plan on the basis of religion, race, color, or national origin with designated exceptions; from expending any resources on diversity, equity, and inclusion, the promotion of discriminatory topics, or bias incident investigations; from soliciting statements on an applicant's experience with or views on religion, race, sex, color, or national origin; from requiring a course dedicated to discriminatory concepts; or disseminating or profiting from any research, work product, or material that promotes or justifies discriminatory concepts; prohibit a public postsecondary education institution from requiring any individual to endorse or condemn a specific ideology or viewpoint; prohibit the Council on Postsecondary Education from providing differential treatment or benefits on the basis of an individual's religion, race, sex, color, or national origin or from expending any resources on diversity, equity, and inclusion or discriminatory topics; establish exclusions for legal compliance; require each governing board of a public postsecondary education institution to ensure compliance with specific sections of this Act no later than June 30, 2025; authorize the Attorney General to bring an action for a writ of mandamus to compel the council or a public postsecondary education institution to comply; create a cause of action to permit a qualified individual to file a civil action against council or a public postsecondary education institution for injunctive relief and limited damages arising from a violation of certain sections of this Act; waive sovereign and governmental immunity for the limited purpose of bringing this claim; prohibit retaliation; require each public postsecondary education institution to submit and publish a certified annual report on governmentally mandated discrimination to the Legislative Research Commission by October 1 each year; provide that a public postsecondary education institution or the council cannot claim a federal, state, judicial, contractual, or accreditation mandate as a defense to a civil action filed under this Act unless the policy, practice, or procedure upon which the complaint is founded is listed and clearly and accurately described in the public institution's annual report filed in accordance with this Act; require each public postsecondary education institution to provide the Personnel Cabinet and State Treasurer the name, job title, duty station, and salary or wages of each employee each month beginning January 1, 2025, and to post its itemized annual budget; amend KRS 164.020 to prohibit the Council on Postsecondary Education from approving a degree, certificate, or diploma program that includes discriminatory concepts or diversity, equity, and inclusion iniatives; amend KRS 164.011, 164.131, 164.321, and 164.821 to conform; direct the Council on Postsecondary Education to consider certain enumerated conditions when considering the elimination of an existing program; direct each public postsecondary education institution and the Council on Postsecondary Education to discontinue designated programs and follow designated procedures when implementing this Act; provide specific instructions for public postsecondary education institutions and the Council on Postsecondary Education to follow in implementing this Act; direct public postsecondary education institutions and the council to submit a report on implementation of this Act.
Index Headings of Original Version Treasurer - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation, publication
Education, Finance - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity and inclusion activities, penalties
Education, Higher - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation, publication
Education, Higher - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity and inclusion activities, omnibus prohibitions
Education, Vocational - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity and inclusion activities, omnibus prohibitions
Public Officers and Employees - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation, publication
Public Salaries - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation, publication
State Agencies - Council on Postsecondary Education, diversity, equity, and inclusion activities, prohibition
State Agencies - Council on Postsecondary Education, diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, elimination
State Agencies - Personnel Cabinet, public postsecondary institutions, employee compensation, publication
State Employees - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation, publication
Universities and Colleges - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity and inclusion activities, omnibus prohibitions
Attorney General - Public postsecondary education, use of resources on diversity, equity, and inclusion, civil action
Civil Actions - Public postsecondary institution, differential treatment or benefits on the basis of protected class
Civil Actions - Public postsecondary institution, use of resources on diversity, equity, and inclusion, civil action
Civil Rights - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity and inclusion activities, prohibition
Claims - Public postsecondary education, use of resources on diversity, equity, and inclusion, civil action
Claims - Public postsecondary institution, differential treatment or benefits on the basis of protected class
Reports Mandated - Public postsecondary education institutions, annual report on federally mandated discrimination
Jump to Proposed Amendments House Committee Substitute 1
House Committee Amendment 1
House Floor Amendment 1
House Floor Amendment 2
House Floor Amendment 3
House Floor Amendment 4
House Floor Amendment 5
House Floor Amendment 6
House Floor Amendment 7
Senate Floor Amendment 1
Senate Floor Amendment 2
Senate Floor Amendment 3
Senate Floor Amendment 4
Senate Floor Amendment 5
Senate Floor Amendment 6
Senate Floor Amendment 7
Senate Floor Amendment 8
Senate Floor Amendment 9
Senate Floor Amendment 10
Senate Floor Amendment 11
Senate Floor Amendment 12
Senate Floor Amendment 13
Senate Floor Amendment 14
Senate Floor Amendment 15
Senate Floor Amendment 16
Senate Floor Amendment 17
Senate Floor Amendment 18
Senate Floor Amendment 19
Votes Vote History

Actions

Top | Amendments
02/12/25
  • introduced in House
  • to Committee on Committees (H)
02/14/25
  • to Postsecondary Education (H)
02/28/25
  • taken from Postsecondary Education (H)
  • 1st reading
  • returned to Postsecondary Education (H)
03/04/25
  • reported favorably, 2nd reading, to Rules with Committee Substitute (1) and Committee Amendment (1-title)
  • floor amendments (1), (2), (3), (4), (5), (6) and (7) filed to Committee Substitute
  • posted for passage in the Regular Orders of the Day for Wednesday, March 05, 2025
03/05/25
  • 3rd reading
  • Floor Amendments (1) and (6) defeated
  • Floor Amendment (2) ruled out of order
  • passed 81-18 with Committee Substitute (1), Floor Amendment (7) and Committee Amendment (1-title)
03/06/25
  • received in Senate
  • to Committee on Committees (S)
  • to Education (S)
  • taken from Education (S)
  • 1st reading
  • returned to Education (S)
03/07/25
  • taken from Education (S)
  • 2nd reading
  • returned to Education (S)
  • Floor Amendments (1), (2), (3), (4), (5), (6), (7), (8), (9), (10), (11), (12), (13), (14), (15) and (16) filed
03/11/25
  • reported favorably, to Rules
  • floor amendment (17) filed to bill, floor amendment (18) filed to Committee Substitute, floor amendment (19-title) filed
  • posted for passage in the Regular Orders of the Day for Tuesday, March 11, 2025
  • passed over and retained in the Orders of the Day

Proposed Amendments

Top | Actions
Amendment House Committee Substitute 1
Summary Retain original provisions, except define an additional term; remove provisions allowing a cause of action by a qualified individual against the council or a public postsecondary education institution for a violation of certain sections; direct the Auditor of Public Accounts to conduct a compliance audit to determine whether an institution spent money in violation of this Act at least once every four years and set forth the procedure to cure or appeal a violation; create a new section of KRS 335B.020 to 335B.070 to prohibit a licensing authority from requiring diversity, equity, and inclusion trainings as a prerequisite to licensing or as grounds for discipline; provide that previous diversity, equity, and inclusion training requirements are void; amend KRS 335B.010 to define terms.
Index Headings Education, Finance - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, private civil action, removal
Education, Higher - Diversity, equity, and inclusion spending, periodic compliance audit
Education, Higher - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, private civil action, removal
Licensing - Diversity, equity, and inclusion, licensure requirement, prohibition
Occupations and Professions - Diversity, equity, and inclusion, licensure requirement, prohibition
Universities and Colleges - Diversity, equity, and inclusion spending, periodic compliance audit
Universities and Colleges - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, private civil action, removal
Auditor of Public Accounts - Diversity, equity, and inclusion spending, periodic compliance audit, frequency and appeals
Civil Actions - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, private civil action, removal
Claims - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, private civil action, removal
Workforce - Diversity, equity, and inclusion spending, periodic compliance audit, frequency and appeals
Workforce - Diversity, equity, and inclusion, licensure requirement, prohibition

Amendment House Committee Amendment 1
Sponsor J. Tipton
Summary Make title amendment.
Index Headings Title Amendments - HB 4

Amendment House Floor Amendment 1
Sponsor A. Donworth
Summary Retain original provisions except restrict the definition of "resource" to moneys appropriated by the General Assembly.
Index Headings Education, Finance - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, restriction of resource use, limit to appropriations
Education, Higher - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, restriction of resource use, limit to appropriations
Universities and Colleges - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, restriction of resource use, limit to appropriations

Amendment House Floor Amendment 2
Sponsor E. Hancock
Summary Retain all original provisions except remove the requirements that each public postsecondary education institution provide the Personnel Cabinet and State Treasurer the name, job title, duty station, and salary or wages of each employee each month beginning January 1, 2025, and to post its itemized annual budget.
Index Headings Education, Finance - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
Education, Higher - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
Public Officers and Employees - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
Public Salaries - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
State Employees - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
Treasurer - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
Universities and Colleges - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal

Amendment House Floor Amendment 3
Sponsor S. Stalker
Summary Retain all original provisions and specifically exclude faculty and staff sponsorship of student-led organizations from the prohibitions of Section 2 of this Act.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Public postsecondary education, student-led organizations, faculty sponsorship, protections
Universities and Colleges - Public postsecondary education, student-led organizations, faculty sponsorship, protections

Amendment House Floor Amendment 4
Sponsor L. Willner
Summary Retain all original provisions except remove the prohibition of a licensing authority from requiring diversity, equity, and inclusion trainings as a prerequisite to licensing or as grounds for discipline,
Index Headings Licensing - Diversity, equity, and inclusion, licensure requirement, removal of prohibition
Occupations and Professions - Diversity, equity, and inclusion, licensure requirement, removal of prohibition
Workforce - Diversity, equity, and inclusion, licensure requirement, removal of prohibition

Amendment House Floor Amendment 5
Sponsor J. Watkins
Summary Retain all original provisions and provide that nothing in Section 2 of the Act shall be construed to apply to or affect scholarships not administered by an institution.
Index Headings Education, Finance - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, exclude unaffiliated scholarships
Education, Higher - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, exclude unaffiliated scholarships
Universities and Colleges - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, exclude unaffiliated scholarships

Amendment House Floor Amendment 6
Sponsor G. Brown Jr.
Summary Retain all provisions except delete restrictions on bias incident investigations.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Bias incident investigations, permissibility
Universities and Colleges - Bias incident investigations, permissibility

Amendment House Floor Amendment 7
Sponsor J. Decker
Summary Retain all original provisions, except remove the requirements that each public postsecondary education institution provide the Personnel Cabinet and State Treasurer with the name, job title, duty station, and salary or wages of each employee each month beginning January 1, 2025, and to post the institution's itemized annual budget; limit the Council on Postsecondary Education's approval restrictions on new programs to programs that include a course or training of which the primary purpose is to indoctrinate participants with a discriminatory concept.
Index Headings Education, Finance - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
Education, Higher - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
Education, Higher - Council on Postsecondary Education, program approval restrictions, indoctrination
Public Officers and Employees - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
Public Salaries - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
State Agencies - Council on Postsecondary Education, program approval restrictions, indoctrination
State Employees - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
Treasurer - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
Universities and Colleges - Public postsecondary education institutions, employee compensation publication, removal
Universities and Colleges - Council on Postsecondary Education, program approval restrictions, indoctrination

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 1
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Retain all original provisions, except remove the prohibition of a licensing authority from requiring diversity, equity, and inclusion trainings as a prerequisite to licensing or as grounds for discipline.
Index Headings Licensing - Diversity, equity, and inclusion, licensure requirement, removal of prohibition
Occupations and Professions - Diversity, equity, and inclusion, licensure requirement, removal of prohibition
Workforce - Diversity, equity, and inclusion, licensure requirement, removal of prohibition

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 2
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Retain all original provisions and provide that nothing in Section 2 of the Act shall be construed to apply to or affect scholarships not administered by an institution.
Index Headings Education, Finance - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, exclude unaffiliated scholarships
Education, Higher - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, exclude unaffiliated scholarships
Universities and Colleges - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, exclude unaffiliated scholarships

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 3
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Retain all provisions, except delete restrictions on bias incident investigations.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Bias incident investigations, permissibility
Universities and Colleges - Bias incident investigations, permissibility

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 4
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Retain all original provisions and specifically exclude faculty and staff sponsorship of student-led organizations from the prohibitions of Section 2 of this Act.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Public postsecondary education, student-led organizations, faculty sponsorship, protections
Universities and Colleges - Public postsecondary education, student-led organizations, faculty sponsorship, protections

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 5
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Retain original provisions, except restrict the definition of "resource" to moneys appropriated by the General Assembly.
Index Headings Education, Finance - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, restriction of resource use, limit to appropriations
Education, Higher - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, restriction of resource use, limit to appropriations
Universities and Colleges - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, restriction of resource use, limit to appropriations

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 6
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Retain all provisions, except replace term "differential treatment or benefits" with "prejudicial treatment or benefits."
Index Headings Education, Higher - Diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, prejudicial treatment or benefits
Universities and Colleges - Diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, prejudicial treatment or benefits
Civil Rights - Diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, prejudicial treatment or benefits

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 7
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Delete all provisions; provide that a public postsecondary education institution shall not use a race-based admissions policy.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Race-based admissions policies; prohibition
Universities and Colleges - Race-based admissions policies; prohibition
Civil Rights - Public postsecondary education institutions, race-based admissions policies; prohibition

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 8
Sponsor K. Herron
Summary Retain original provisions, except include profession and county or region of residency among the list of characteristics that cannot be the basis of differential treatment or benefits throughout the bill.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, profession and county of residence, inclusion
Universities and Colleges - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, profession and county of residence, inclusion

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 9
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Retain original provisions, except remove prohibitions related to soliciting or considering applicants statements related to experience with or views on religion, race, sex, color, or national origin.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Diversity statements, permission to consider, prohibition to compel
Universities and Colleges - Diversity statements, permission to consider, prohibition to compel
Civil Rights - Diversity statements, permission to consider, prohibition to compel

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 10
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Maintain provisions related to providing differential treatment or benefits in the context of student admissions; delete all other provisions related to differential treatment or benefits in other contexts; retain all other provisions.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, student admissions, prohibition
Universities and Colleges - Diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, student admissions, prohibition
Civil Rights - Diversity, equity, and inclusion initiatives, student admissions, prohibition

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 11
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Retain original provisions; provide that nothing in Section 2 is to restrict public universities from collaborating with private sector partners, workforce development organizations, or community programs.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Private sector partnerships, exclusion from scope of diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions
Universities and Colleges - Private sector partnerships, exclusion from scope of diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions
Civil Rights - Private sector partnerships, exclusion from scope of diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 12
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Require that nothing in the Act is to prohibit programs designed to enhance student retention, mentorship, academic advising, or career development, provided these programs do not grant preferential treatment based on race.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, limitations
Licensing - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, limitations
Universities and Colleges - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, limitations
Workforce - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, limitations
Education, Finance - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, limitations

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 13
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Require that nothing in the Act is to be construed to permit discrimination or exclusion based on religion, including but not limited to policies, programs, or decisions that result in anti-Semitic actions; require public universities and K-12 institutions to ensure that all diversity, equity, and inclusion efforts, student success initiatives, and institutional policies remain inclusive and do not create a hostile environment for individuals based on religious identity.
Index Headings Education, Finance - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, limitations
Education, Higher - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, limitations
Licensing - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, limitations
Universities and Colleges - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, limitations
Workforce - Public postsecondary education, diversity, equity, and inclusion, limitations

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 14
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Retain original provisions; require that nothing in Section 2 restricts faculty members’ academic freedom in curriculum development, professional development, research, or classroom discussions, provided such activities comply with existing federal and state nondiscrimination laws.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, exclude academic freedom
Universities and Colleges - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, exclude academic freedom
Civil Rights - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, exclude academic freedom

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 15
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Retain original provisions; provide that nothing in Section 2 shall restrict the use of college affordability programs, scholarships, or grants based on socioeconomic status, first-generation college status, or other race-neutral criteria designed to increase access to higher education.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, preserve college affordability programs
Universities and Colleges - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, preserve college affordability programs
Civil Rights - Diversity, equity, and inclusion prohibitions, preserve college affordability programs

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 16
Sponsor G. Neal
Summary Retain original provisions; require that institutions retain the right to collect and analyze demographic data for institutional research, accreditation, compliance with federal reporting requirements, and assessment of student outcomes, provided such data is not used as a factor in admissions decisions.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Diversity, equity, and inclusion omnibus prohibitions, exclusion of data collection from scope
Universities and Colleges - Diversity, equity, and inclusion omnibus prohibitions, exclusion of data collection from scope

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 17
Sponsor G. Williams
Summary Retain all original provisions; add a penalty of 1% of all state-appropriated funds for an institution that is found by the State Auditor to have spent money in violation of Section 2 of this Act for 2 or more audits within a 10 year period.
Index Headings Education, Finance - Public postsecondary audits of diversity, equity, and inclusion spending, penalty for second offense
Education, Higher - Public postsecondary audits of diversity, equity, and inclusion spending, penalty for second offense
Treasurer - Public postsecondary audits of diversity, equity, and inclusion spending, penalty for second offense
Universities and Colleges - Public postsecondary audits of diversity, equity, and inclusion spending, penalty for second offense
Auditor of Public Accounts - Public postsecondary audits of diversity, equity, and inclusion spending, penalty for second offense

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 18
Sponsor G. Williams
Summary Retain all original provisions; create a cause of action to permit a qualified individual to file a civil action against council or a public postsecondary education institution for injunctive relief and limited damages arising from a violation of certain sections of this Act; waive sovereign and governmental immunity for the limited purpose of bringing this claim; prohibit retaliation.
Index Headings Education, Higher - Public postsecondary education, use of resources on diversity, equity, and inclusion, civil action
Universities and Colleges - Public postsecondary education, use of resources on diversity, equity, and inclusion, civil action
Claims - Public postsecondary education, use of resources on diversity, equity, and inclusion, civil action

Amendment Senate Floor Amendment 19
Sponsor S. West
Summary Make title amendment.
Index Headings Title Amendments - HB 4

Last updated: 3/11/2025 9:25 PM (EDT)